The Insurance Producers Guild
The Insurance Producers Guild is a strategic briefing for insurance professionals, focused on Medicare, ACA, life insurance, and the evolving insurance landscape. Each episode distills complex industry changes into clear, practical intelligence.
AI was used in the making of these podcasts.
The Insurance Producers Guild
EP 28 Surviving Medicare Advantage Zero Dollar Commissions
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
CMS calls 2027 Medicare Advantage "stable," with the average premium dropping from $14.37 to $12.00. Yet beneficiaries average 35 plans, down from 39 (KFF), and out-of-pocket maximums rise 9.1% (Fierce Healthcare).
Special Needs Plans drove 85% of MA growth (AmeriLife Insights). The max MA commission rises to $725, but Aetna pays $0 on 123 plans in 33 states (MedicalDaily).
Here's how to review every client and pick the right plan, paid or not.
🔑 Key Topics Covered
- 2027 premiums, plan counts, and county cuts
- PPO to HMO shift and higher out-of-pocket maximums
- SNP growth and shifting carrier share
- $725 max commissions and $0-commission plans
🎯 What This Means for Agents
- Review doctors, drugs, and the out-of-pocket max, not just premium
- Know which plans pay before the appointment
- Learn SNPs and diversify carrier contracts
- Never steer by commission. Recommend what fits and document why
🔗 Sources
CMS:
https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/medicare-advantage-medicare-prescription-drug-programs-expected-remain-stable-2027
Fierce Healthcare:
https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/payers/focus-hmos-c-snps-look-medicare-advantage-landscape-2027
CMS: Contract Year 2027 Agent and Broker Compensation Rates (memo, June 1, 2026)
https://advocacy.naifa.org/hubfs/CMS%20memo.6.5.pdf
MedicalDaily:
https://www.medicaldaily.com/aetna-medicare-advantage-broker-commission-freeze-2027-477523
AmeriLife Insights:
https://amerilife.com/insights/medicare/rebuild-your-aep-playbook-for-the-new-ma-market
📌 GO-DO: Review Benefits, Know the Grid
Call clients hit by county cuts, PPO exits, or higher out-of-pocket maximums first, and check their doctors, drugs, and max. Know every 2027 commission grid before appointments, recommend what fits, and document why. Contracting Support can help you add carriers.
Infographic: https://www.psmbrokerage.com/hubfs/The%20Insurance%20Producers%20Guild/IPG_EP28_Infographic.pdf
Slides:
https://www.psmbrokerage.com/hubfs/The%20Insurance%20Producers%20Guild/IPG_EP28_Slides.pdf
The Insurance Producers Guild Podcast delivers intelligence for insurance agents looking to stay ahead of industry trends.
Follow the show and connect with PSM Brokerage to access tools, training, and support designed to help you grow your business.
Learn more: https://www.psmbrokerage.com
Picture this, you know, your phone rings, it's your client, and they sound well incredibly relieved.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I know exactly where this is going.
SPEAKER_01Right. They say, um, I just saw the news that Medicare premiums are going down, so I'm fine doing nothing this year.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00They just want to keep what they have.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. But uh at that exact same moment, you're sitting at your desk, staring at a 2027 commission grid, realizing that a plan you actively write is paying absolutely zero for new enrollments this year.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell And it might even be the exact plan that client is enrolled in.
SPEAKER_01It really might. And that is the stark reality of the market right now. Welcome to this deep dive for the Insurance Producers Guild by PSM Brokerage, a national FMO serving independent insurance agents in all 50 states.
SPEAKER_00So glad to be here.
SPEAKER_01Our mission today is to unpack these two, well, very different sides of the 2027 annual enrollment period market. We've got fresh data from CMS, Fierce Healthcare, KFF, and Medical News.
SPEAKER_00Lots of ground to cover.
SPEAKER_01We are gonna break down exactly what is happening beneath the surface, what you need to say to your clients, and uh what you need to do this week.
SPEAKER_00It really is the ultimate dual anxiety for an agent right now. The client thinks everything is perfect, and the agent feels like the floor just fell out. But I've been through this cycle before. I've seen these market shifts happen in waves, and we need to dissolve both of those fears right out of the gate.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell How do we do that?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, the average premium making headlines on the news is not your client's specific plan. And that zero dollar commission grid, that's not your recommendation.
SPEAKER_01That's a great point.
SPEAKER_00The agent who retains their book this year is the one who thoroughly reviews benefits and networks and who memorizes that commission grid long before they ever step foot in the client's home.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Let's start with the headline the client is seeing. Because CMS issued a press release on September 28th, explicitly calling the 2027 market stable.
SPEAKER_00Stable, right.
SPEAKER_01Stable. And um the numbers they lead with, they look fantastic on paper. The weighted average Medicare Advantage premium is dropping 16.5%. Wow. It's going from uh $14.37 down to $12. And the Part D prescription drug portion is dropping 38%.
SPEAKER_00Right. And CMS also says 97% of beneficiaries still have like 10 or more Medicare Advantage choices.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Exactly. I mean, even CMS administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz is urging beneficiaries to review and compare. So on the surface, the consumer just sees stable and cheaper.
SPEAKER_00They do, but you know, we have to look at the pattern. When the headline premium stays at zero or drops, the cost change doesn't just evaporate.
SPEAKER_01It has to go somewhere.
SPEAKER_00It inevitably moves elsewhere. The premium is just the front door. We have to look at the rest of the house. Right. Insurance carriers are facing intense margin pressure. So to keep that front door looking attractive, they are tightening the screws on the back end.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell I really have to challenge the idea of this being stable, though. Because when you look at the data from KFF and Fierce Healthcare, the engine under the hood looks like it's sputtering.
SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01The average beneficiary's Medicare Advantage plan choices are actually down from 39 to 35. Medicare Advantage prescription drug options drop to 28.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell And individual plan footprints are actively shrinking across the board. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Aetna and Elevance are down 5% in the counties they serve. Centeen is down 20%.
SPEAKER_00That's a huge pullback.
SPEAKER_01It is. Meanwhile, Stevens' data shows the average out-of-pocket maximum is up 9.1%. It's like squeezing a balloon. You know, you push down the premium on one end and the system bulges out on the other end with higher out-of-pocket maximums and vanishing PPOs.
SPEAKER_00That bulge is exactly where the industry is shifting, specifically toward HMOs. Learing partners put out a note highlighting this exact mechanism.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell What did they find?
SPEAKER_00Insurers are actively prioritizing margins by cutting benefits, raising member cost sharing, and withdrawing PPOs. United Healthcare is the prime example here.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00They are heavily emphasizing HMOs, growing their HMO count to 7,09, even as their total individual Medicare Advantage plans shrink.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So mechanically speaking, why does an insurance carrier prefer an HMO over a PPO when margins are tight?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell It comes down to cost control and predictability. A PPO is essentially an open network. Clients can self-refer to specialists, they can go out of network, and the carrier has uh far less control over the ultimate bill.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Makes sense.
SPEAKER_00But an HMO is tightly coordinated. Think of an HMO primary care doctor like a like a general contractor building a house.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Ooh, I like that analogy.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Yeah. If you're building a house, you don't just randomly call an electrician and start authorizing work. The general contractor has to look at the blueprints, authorize the specific work, and then bring the electrician in.
SPEAKER_01Right, because that's how they control the budget.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Exactly. In an HMO, the primary care doctor manages the budget by requiring a referral before a specialist ever gets involved.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So you're going to be sitting across from clients who have always had a PPO. They are used to self-referring, you know, calling their own electrician, so to speak. Yep. How do you explain that shift to them plainly when their PPO disappears or the benefits get slashed?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell You keep it grounded in the trade-off they are making. You tell them, look, to keep your premium at zero this year, the insurance company needs to tightly coordinate your care. Right. And that means your primary care doctor is going to act like the general contractor for your health. If you need a specialist, your primary care doctor has to write the referral first to make sure it's necessary and in network.
SPEAKER_01It sets the expectation clearly that tighter networks and referrals are just the new reality for maintaining those low upfront costs.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_01So if the general enrollment traditional PPO market is shrinking, and networks are tightening to protect margins, that poses a logical question for the agent listening right now. Where should an agent actually focus to find growth?
SPEAKER_00You follow the data. Federico Guardia, the president of PSM Brokerage, broke this down in his recent analysis. He pointed out that overall Medicare Advantage enrollment is over 35 million. That's up 3%.
SPEAKER_01Right. But what about general enrollment?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, general enrollment individual plans had their slowest growth since 2007. They added just 224,000 members.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell That is incredibly sluggish.
SPEAKER_00Trevor Burrus It really is. Because the real story, the place where things are actually moving, is special needs plans or SNPs. They drove a massive 85% of the net growth.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Wow, 85%.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Yeah. And this ties directly into the footprint shifts we were just talking about. Carriers are adjusting their strategies based on these specific demographics.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Can you give an example?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Sure. So while United Healthcare exited 109 counties and displaced roughly 180,000 members for 2026, Humana added 1.3 million, and smaller regional carriers added 734,000.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So the growth is fracturing, it's moving into niche plans and spreading out across way more carriers. Let's break down what that means for an agent strategy this week.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Okay, let's do it.
SPEAKER_01First, you have to learn the eligibility rules for special needs plans, specifically the dual eligible D SNPs for clients on Medicaid and chronic condition C SNPs.
SPEAKER_00Right, because the growth is heavily concentrated there. You have to master the care coordination and required documentation for those markets.
SPEAKER_01And second, you must diversify your carrier contracts.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. When growth shifts so heavily to SNPs and spreads across smaller carriers, a book tied to just one or two carriers is highly exposed.
SPEAKER_01If you only write two logos and one of them exits your county, you're scrambling to find a home for your clients.
SPEAKER_00Which means the third step is moving early. With clients in those known exit counties, do not wait for them to get the displacement letter in the mail and panic call an 800 number. Don't let that happen.
SPEAKER_01And look, PSM Brokerage is a national FMO serving all 50 states, and their contracting support team is specifically set up to help you add these carriers before you actually need them.
SPEAKER_00You want those contracts active in your portfolio before you walk into the client's house.
SPEAKER_01Preparation is the only defense against a contracting bottleneck in October. Which brings us to the most critical operational reality of this AEP: the commission grids. Right. Because if carrier margin pressures forcing cuts to networks and shifting growth into special needs plans, that margin pressure has to roll downhill.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell And it is rolling right onto the agent's commission grid.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01The June 1 CMS memo stated that the commission ceiling actually went up. Initial Medicare advantage maximums rose from $694 to $725.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell With renewals going from $347 up to $363. Aaron Powell Right.
SPEAKER_01And standalone prescription drug plan initial commissions went from $114 up to $130.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell The ceiling went up, yes. But um carriers can pay up to that maximum or they can pay nothing at all. The floor is zero.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell And Medical News just published a report revealing exactly what that floor looks like in practice.
SPEAKER_00It's rough.
SPEAKER_01Aetna is paying no new enrollment commission on 123 Medicare Advantage plans across 33 states. That impacts roughly 780 counties.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell That's a massive shift.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell And they are paying absolutely nothing on new standalone prescription drug plans either.
SPEAKER_00Unbelievable.
SPEAKER_01Wait, I have to challenge this because this is where agents panic. If a carrier drops the commission to zero, aren't they basically telling agents, we don't want this business? Why wouldn't an agent just assume the plan is going to be terrible for their client anyway and avoid writing it?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell I get why people think that, but no. Because the benefits of the plan do not change just because of a commission decision.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Okay, so the plans still exist.
SPEAKER_00They absolutely still exist. Current members keep their exact same coverage. A commission adjustment is simply a risk mitigation strategy by the carrier.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell How does that work?
SPEAKER_00Think about the mechanism here. If a carrier has a plan that is running incredibly hot, meaning the enrollees are using a lot of expensive health care, the carrier might not want to cancel the plan entirely and disrupt their current members, but they also don't want a massive influx of new members jumping into that specific risk pool. By dropping the broker commission to zero, it acts as a silent valve to shut off new enrollment.
SPEAKER_01Ah, I see.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It is a business decision to manage their internal margins, not a reflection of the plan's medical benefits for the consumer. Aaron Powell Okay.
SPEAKER_01So the plan might still be the absolute best fit for the client's specific doctors and medications. But here's where it gets really complicated for the agent.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Medical Daily is actively telling seniors to ask their agents if they are being paid on the plans they are shown.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell They're warning consumers that unpaid brokers might quietly drop certain plans from the menu.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. So your client might literally look you in the eye, point to the brochure, and ask, are you getting paid to put me in this one?
SPEAKER_00And you have to have an honest answer ready.
SPEAKER_01You do. As someone who focuses heavily on sales technique and closing, I actually practice what I'm going to say in these moments.
SPEAKER_00What's your approach?
SPEAKER_01I look right at them, and here is what I say, word for word, to handle it ethically and completely neutralize their skepticism. I say, Mrs. Jones, my job is to find the plan that covers your doctors and prescriptions best. Some plans pay me, and some don't pay me at all for new enrollments this year. But I work for you, not the insurance company. If the best fit is a plan that doesn't pay me, I will still recommend it and we will get you enrolled.
SPEAKER_00I love that.
SPEAKER_01That changes the entire dynamic of the room. It enforces the golden rule of AEP survival. Which is to deliver that script confidently, you must pull every single carrier's 2027 commission grid before your appointments. A zero dollar plan should never be a surprise when you are sitting at the kitchen table mid-review.
SPEAKER_00Never.
SPEAKER_01You cannot be frantically swiping under your tablet trying to figure out if a plan pays you while the client is reading off their medication list.
SPEAKER_00No, you have to know the math before you knock on the door.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell And the compliance point here is plain and simple. An agent must never steer a client toward a plan because it pays or away from one because it does not.
SPEAKER_00Period.
SPEAKER_01You recommend the plan that fits the doctors, the drugs, and the budget.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Because this market environment requires absolute trust. We are operating in a landscape where choices are slightly down, out-of-pocket maximums are up, and networks are tightening into HMOs. Trust is built on transparency and doing the right thing, regardless of what the grid says.
SPEAKER_01So let's distill all of this down to your mission for this week. The 2027 AEP requires recognizing market patterns. You need to prepare your clients for the shift to HMOs and hire out-of-pocket maximums.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Explaining the general contractor concept clearly.
SPEAKER_01Yep. You need to diversify into special needs plans because that is where 85% of the growth is. And you can use PSM contracting support to expand your portfolio early.
SPEAKER_00And you must maintain absolute trust with your clients by knowing those commission grids in advance and putting their medical needs first.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Well said. I will say the one operational bright spot amidst all of this is that the 48-hour waiting period for the scope of appointment has been rolled back.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that is a massive workflow relief for agents out in the field.
SPEAKER_01It really is.
SPEAKER_00But the core strategy remains the same: preparation and adaptation.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell I want to leave you with a final thought to mull over as you prep your materials this week. Medical Daily pointed out that plan level commission reporting is voluntary and not public.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Because of that, seniors are actively being trained by the media right now to be skeptical of their broker's motives. They are expecting you to hide things.
SPEAKER_00They really are.
SPEAKER_01So what if, in a market where other agents are trying to quietly sidestep zero commission plans, you use radical, unprompted transparency about how you get paid as your ultimate competitive advantage.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01What if you bring it up before they even ask? Think about how quickly that breaks down their defenses and locks in client loyalty for life.
SPEAKER_00It proves that you actually are the expert working on their behalf, not just an order taker for the carrier.
SPEAKER_01It really does. So when that phone rings and they ask about those premiums dropping, you know exactly how to guide them through the whole house, not just the front door. Thanks for joining us on this deep dive into the 2027 market data. Go pull your grids, learn your special needs plans, and go have a great week.